You’re a few steps into these community-favorite bran muffins when you realize: Uh-oh, no molasses in sight. The recipe only calls for three tablespoons—so can you swap it out? Good news: Yes, you definitely can. Whether you’re baking cookies, mixing BBQ sauce, or whipping up gingerbread, there’s a molasses substitute for you. Below, we’re diving into what molasses actually is, how it behaves in recipes, and the best molasses alternatives to use in a pinch (including two more options for subbing barley malt and date syrup, per your comments!).
Mosser 3-Piece Colored Glass Mixing Bowl Set
$89–$115
More Colors
<div class="basketModalMounts" data-product-id="5086" data-product-name="Mosser 3-Piece Colored Glass Mixing Bowl Set" data-url="/shop/products/5086-glass-3-piece-mixing-bowl-set" data-img="https://images.food52.com/CCMXOeG6LOEtoLLAygY8sKq7goQ=/520×520/a9c738fb-a0de-4837-8ef0-ca89fc8f76ad–2016-0609_mosser_jadeite-bowls_mid_mark-weinberg_108.jpg" data-price-range="$89–$115” data-ga-event=”gridInteraction” data-ga-event-action=”From Our Shop” data-ga-event-label=”none” data-ga-destination-url=”/shop/products/5086-glass-3-piece-mixing-bowl-set” data-ga-index=”0″>
What is molasses, anyway?
Simply put, molasses is a byproduct of sugar processing, whether that’s sugar cane or sugar beets. When sugar is refined, “the juice squeezed from these plants is boiled to a syrupy mixture from which sugar crystals are extracted,” according to The New Food Lover’s Companion. “The remaining brownish-black liquid is molasses.” Got it!
